This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
seceng-course-exp-2013 [2014/07/16 15:15] martina.degramatica@unitn.it [A Experiment on Comparing Textual vs Visual Industrial Methods for Security Risk Assessment] |
seceng-course-exp-2013 [2021/01/29 10:58] (current) |
||
---|---|---|---|
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
An experiment by Katsyarina Labunets, Fabio Massacci, Federica Paci. | An experiment by Katsyarina Labunets, Fabio Massacci, Federica Paci. | ||
- | This page provides additional resources that enable replication of our work published at {{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:empire-2014.pdf|EMPIRE2014}}. | + | This page provides additional resources that enable replication of our work published at {{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:empire-2014.pdf|EmpiRE2014}}. See the [[validation_of_risk_and_security_requirements_methodologies|main page]] for our work on empirical validation of security risk assessment methods and other experiments. |
===== Goals ===== | ===== Goals ===== | ||
Line 49: | Line 49: | ||
- | ==== Supplement Materials ==== | + | ===== Additional Material ===== |
- | During the experiment we distributed among participants two type of questionnaires: | + | * For additional information on the experimental design please see the {{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:experiment-description.pdf|Experimental Protocol}}. |
- | * Pre-task questionnaire to collect some information about participants and thier background: {{:research_activities:experiments:2013-2014-se-exp:seceng2013-2014-background.pdf|Q1}}. | + | * For privacy reasons, at the beginning of the experiment a {{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:consent-form-security-engineering.pdf|Consent Form }} was administered to participants. |
- | * Post-task questionnaire to collect participants' perception of methods: {{:research_activities:experiments:2013-2014-se-exp:seceng2013-2014-post-task-questionnaire.pdf|Q2}}. | + | * To protect the confidentiality of the training materials provided, participants were asked to sign a {{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:2014-trento-securityengineering-nda.docx|Non-Disclosure Agreement |
- | For individual interview we used the following interview guide: {{:research_activities:experiments:2013-2014-se-exp:seceng2013-2014-interviewguide.pdf|guide}}. | + | }}. |
+ | * Participants' results have been assessed by methods and domain experts ({{:research_activities:experiments:2014-seceng:evaluation_score_template.xlsx|Evaluation Score Sheet}}). | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | **Data collected during the experiment are available upon request.** |